Categorized in | Campus News, News

By Rachel David
Published: September 21, 2009
By Rachel David

Daily Titan Copy Editor

Tenure-track and tenured CSUF faculty members explain the six year process and give their own personal insight on it.

Tenure is an act revered on university campuses, not excluding Cal State Fullerton. A total of 418 current CSUF faculty members have successfully fulfilled the rigorous requirements of the tenure process. Students often do not understand what tenure is, or the review process that tenure-track faculty must submit to.

“Tenure is strictly for faculty positions covered under the CSU/CFA (California Faculty Association) Collective Bargaining Agreement (Unit 3 Faculty Union). Librarians are covered by the Collective Bargaining Agreement and are considered faculty,”stated Robin Graboyes, director of Faculty Affairs and Records.

Graboyes went on to add, “Tenure is only granted to professors who are hired into an ongoing/tenure-track position (as opposed to a temporary appointment with a start and end date) and only if they obtain a terminal degree in their field of study, which is usually a Ph.D.”

The break down of tenured faculty on campus, according to Faculty Affairs and Records, is as follows: 114 in the College of Humanities and Social Sciences, 56 in the College of Natural Sciences and Mathematics, 52 in both the College of the Arts and the College of Business and Economics, 41 in the College of Health and Human Development, 37 in the College of Communications, 34 in the College of Education, 24 in the College of Engineering and Computer Science, and eight in Pollak Library.
The tenure review process, restricted for full-time tenure-track faculty only, consists of three categories: teaching, research and service, with teaching and research weighted more heavily. Each CSU tenure-track faculty member must adhere to the standard UPS 210.000 document, which is the “overarching university-level document that guides the RTP (Retention, Tenure, Promotion) process,” states a document found on the Faculty Affairs and Records Web site.

However, some disciplines have additional guidelines not listed in the UPS 210 document that faculty must fulfill in order to satisfy the six-year probationary tenure-track requirements.

As Graboyes pointed out, “Biology would have different needs than someone in the arts, for example.”

If a tenure-track faculty member does not receive tenure, then they must leave. They are given a “terminal year,” which is one additional year to teach before having to leave.

“It would affect anyone’s pride (to not get tenure),” said Graboyes. “The faculty work so hard. I respect them so much; they put so much into it. It’s their life. It is very important.”

Tenure-track faculty are required to keep track of their teaching, research and service in a Portfolio – three separate binders provided by Faculty Affairs and Records. According to a document titled “Preparing Your RTP Portfolio” found on the Faculty Affairs and Records Web site, “Non Teaching Faculty (Library and Counseling) are evaluated based on their performance in the position/profession in place of teaching.”

Dr. Lana Dalley, an assistant and tenure-track professor of English at CSUF, described typical documents found within the Portfolio. Published articles and/or books fall under the research umbrella, while lesson plans, syllabi, student opinion questionnaires, and a minimum of two teaching observations can be found in the teaching section. Documentation of service, both on campus and in the surrounding community, can include agendas from meetings. Dalley, who is on Academic Senate and the adviser for Sigma Tau Delta, the International English Honor Society at CSUF, includes paperwork from both meetings into her Portfolio.

Dalley, who is in her third year of the probationary tenure process, said, “At CSUF, it’s a very transparent process, nobody should be surprised if they don’t get it. It is more stressful if it’s not transparent.”

Dr. Mostafa Shiva, chair and professor of the Electrical Engineering Department, has had tenure “for a long time. I would say 15 years, maybe more.” He said it is not easy to get tenure; there are a lot of requirements to satisfy. “UPS is the main document. Some departments and colleges have their own rules that cannot violate UPS, but it can add to it. For electrical engineering, we follow UPS. We don’t have anything extra (to do).”

The number of faculty members in the last five years who went up for tenure but did not receive it is seven; that is less than one percent of those eligible to achieve tenure, according to Faculty Affairs and Records. Dalley said the screening process of faculty admitted to CSUF is very thorough, which helps explains the low percentage of tenure-denied faculty.

  • Share/Bookmark
Print this post

Rachel David has written 12 posts on DailyTitan.com.


Tags: , , , ,


One Response to “Thinking Tenure”

  1. Anonymous says:

    Thanks Rachel, it was nice getting a better idea of what tenured faculty members endure for their positions.


Post a Comment

The Daily Titan wants your comments! Please know that we reserve the right to moderate these. If you'd like to display your photo, go and get a Gravatar.

By submitting this comment, you agree to our commenting policy.

Stay connected

  • Popular
  • Featured
  • Comments
  • Tags
  • Subscribe